 |
| 2014 versus 1987 |
I'm deviating from my usual blog post to bring you an analysis that I've been thinking about for a while now. It's a matter that's very important to me, and I feel I need to share it with the world.
They remade
Robocop. If you are one of those people who say, "What's this
Robocop you speak of?" then I suggest that you go give yourself a time-out. Go on! What is
Robocop?! It's only one of the greatest movies of the 80's and one of my favorite movies of all time! It's a masterpiece of ultraviolence and irreverent satire of consumerism in the 80's.
But anyway, yes, they remade the best movie of the 80's. They remade
Robocop! First of all, you should never remake a movie that was already good. Second of all, if you find yourself remaking a ultra-violent 80's movie into a modern action sci-fi movie with
less violence, you need to go back to your smelly apartment and rethink your entire existence. Is Hollywood so freaking lazy that they're going to pluck a movie that
defines the era it was made in and remake it for dumb movie audiences of today??
Okay, I started ranting a bit there. From now on, I'm going to try to keep my analysis level-headed and professional. Let's begin our comparison of these two films with the setting.
Detroit
Original Robocop:
Detroit was a depraved cesspool of filth, crime, and corruption. It was a horrible place to live. The police were overwhelmed with the rise in crime, and needed some kind of help. A company called Omnicorp manufactured a bunch of robotic police drones called the ED-209s, which were meant to help clean up the streets. However, the drones were found to be unreliable and dangerous, since they were very prone to malfunctions. During a demonstration to a board of administrators, an ED-209 prototype guns down an innocent man, even after he drops his weapon.
Scientists wanted to create the first-ever robotic police officer with the ability to fairly assess situations, efficiently capture criminals, and protect innocent people from harm. After the tragic murder of dedicated cop Alex Murphy, scientists begin their project, rebuilding him into the perfect weapon, with all the raw instincts of a good cop mixed with the efficiency of a machine, just what Detroit needed.
New Robocop:
Future Detroit looks fine. It's a large, clean, future metropolis with fully-functioning robot police drones that
don't malfunction. Their ED-209s never shoot the crap out of a single innocent person. The only chaos in the movie we see takes place in the Middle East, where the drones started gunning down people because they were
trying to blow up all the drones.
Of course the drones are going to kill these people; they were successfully perceived as threats! The explosions could have killed other innocent people, and the drones were trying to prevent that from happening!
So, scientists still want to make a robot cop that can feel emotion. For Detroit. Again, Detroit doesn't need it. We don't see any crime here, and the city looks clean and prosperous. But scientists still think it's necessary to create Robocop so he can clean up crime and feel emotion. Funny thing, they end up taking away his emotions later anyway, so what the hell.
Alex Murphy
Original Robocop:
In the original movie, Alex Murphy, the man who will soon become Robocop, comes off as a friendly, easy-going guy. He's a good cop, and an all-around good guy. His death is rendered horrifying not just because it was gruesome and violent, but because we liked him. When he is rebuilt as Robocop, Murphy becomes stoic and robotic, with no memory of his human life. over the course of the movie, we watch him as he slowly remembers who he is and realizes what has been done to him. He could show real, genuine emotion even with the Robocop face shield down. On top of all that, he's a complete badass.
New Robocop:
Okay, right away I see problems. Just based on the picture, I would guess that Alex Murphy is a jerk. And he is! When the movie starts, the first thing Murphy does is complain at the police chief, actually folding his arms like a pouting toddler. Right away, there's no reason for us to care about this dude. Also, either due to the acting or the directing, the guy playing Murphy shifts inconsistently from robotic to emotional, all before he even
becomes Robocop. Much later, when he's Robocop, he's constantly putting up his face sheild so we can see his entire face when he emotes. While original Robocop only needed his lower jaw to show us how he was feeling, the filmmakers for this movie thought audiences were too stupid for that kind of subtlety, so they went the easy route.
Not only that, but we're
bombarded by scenes of Murphy with his family in order to establish that he's worth caring about. And speaking of his family...
Murphy's Family
Original Robocop:
Murphy's family is mostly absent. Murphy is introduced as a single guy, with nothing much going on in his life other than he's a dedicated cop. It's only after he becomes Robocop that he suddenly begins regaining human memories that we haven't seen yet. He did have a family once; a spunky, loving wife and a happy young son. While we only see glimpses of them, it's still clear that this guy has lost a lot in becoming the ultimate savior of Detroit. Also, as he soon realizes what was done to him, we are further moved to sympathy for him, since he doesn't have that loving family to support him. Murphy's just been turned into a weapon against his will, and his family is no longer around to give him comfort.
New Robocop:
Murphy's family is still around. I had a really big problem with this, since it takes away a bit more of the tragedy of a man being brought back to life as a modern-day Frankenstein's monster, being used by the city of Detroit as a weapon against his will. He has the support of his wife, and he can still be with her and their son, so where's the tragedy in that? On top of that, the woman playing Murphy's wife is incapable of acting and the kid playing their son is completely emotionless.
There's another problem I have with the kid. When Robocop comes home for the first time after being built, the kid just stares at him for a bit, then just starts talking about baseball.
He has no questions about how the scientists rebuilt his previously-dead father. Also, how is he not excited that his dad is now an awesome part-robot cop?! His dad's a real-life superhero, and he has
no reaction to this?! What is wrong with this kid???
Not to mention, when Robocop uses his sensors to detect his kid's emotions, it says things like "frightened" or "scared" or "shocked." But at all of these points, the kid is just staring blankly into the distance. He never cries, throws tantrums, or even looks worried. Maybe Robocop's son is also a robot.
Robocop/Murphy's Best Friend
Original Robocop:
This is Officer Anne Lewis. She was assigned to be Alex Murphy's partner in the beginning of the movie. While their partnership was brief, we saw glimpses of real chemistry and friendship developing between them. Lewis was friendly and loyal, and a good partner to Murphy. When Murphy got brutally murdered by the main bad guy of the movie, she flew right to his side, mourning him even though she only knew him for a short time. After Murphy was rebuilt as Robocop, Lewis was the one that helped him regain his humanity through genuine friendship and support. What Murphy lacked in a family was made up in his new friend.
I think it's also appropriate to mention that Officer Anne Lewis is damn good with a missile launcher.
New Robocop:
In the Robocop remake, they seemed to think that it was a good idea to get rid of Officer Anne Lewis almost completely. Now Murphy's partner is Officer Jack Lewis, a black guy with no distinguishing characteristcs, and no role in the movie. We are never really given a chance to get to know him, he gets shot in the first few minutes of the movie, he gets better a few scenes later, and then he does nothing at all. If he was removed from the movie, the outcomes of the plot would have been exactly the same. I guess Robocop doesn't need him since he has a loving family to go home to.
Ughhh... I'm getting angry..........
No, I'm fine. I can keep it together.
These were only a few major points, but they were some of the most important ones that I considered when comparing the two movies. These weird changes in the characters really stuck out to me in the new
Robocop and I really don't think that they improved the movie's plot at all.
The original Robocop was a fantstic blend of action, violence, tragedy, and comedy that kept me engaged and interested throughout it's run. It's a movie about a robot-cop shooting bad guys, sure, but it also contained some real emotional weight, since I liked the characters, and cared about what happened to them. It's also about a man who had his humanity taken away from him, and his struggle to get it back. It ends on a bittersweet note, with Robocop remembering his human name. He knows his life will never be the same, but at least he has come to terms with what he is, and he knows that he can right the wrong in this world.
The reboot is about a man who was killed in a carbomb, was rebuilt as Robocop, and he shoots things. He has a family that doesn't do anything, a best friend that's hardly in the movie who
also doesn't do anything, and blah blah blah. I couldn't care about him too much because he wasn't that likable to begin with. The movie has a rainbows and butterflies ending, where he gets new armor and goes back home to his family again. Oh, did I mention? He doesn't really loose his human memories. He didn't have to struggle as much emotionally to get them back.
Now I'd like to talk about what made each movie memorable.
The original Robocop was full of memorable moments. And they are as follows:
-the main bad guy murdering Alex Murphy brutally, leading up to the creation of Robocop
-Robocop slipping in and out of consciousness as he is rebuilt by the scientists
-Robocop waking up to the scientists celebrating him and their achievement
-Robocop saving a woman from being raped
-Robocop punching a hole in a wall to grab a man who was holding innocent people hostage
-Robocop regaining his human memories
-Officer Anne Lewis reconnecting with Robocop's human side and helping him kill the bad guys
-"I'd buy that for a dollar!"
-Officer Anne Lewis blowing up the bad guys with a
rocket launcher
-Robocop kicking all of the ass
-Robocop smiling and saying his own name at the end
The new Robocop had very few memorable moments, but there were still memorable moments:
-some good action scenes
-Samuel L. Jackson acting as a satirical Bill O'Rielly type character. I liked that the movie made a statement about the media's tendency to twist the facts in order to fulfill an agenda, or make the people feel a certain way
Also, there is a scene in the new
Robocop that elicited a genuine emotional response from me. After Murphy wakes up and realizes what the scientists did to him, he asks the lead scientist, Gary Oldman, to show him how much of his human body is still left. Gary Oldman then removies all the pieces of his Robocop armor, revealing that all that's left is one hand, a heart, lungs, a head, and a brain. Murphy gasps, and with tears in his eyes says, "My God, there's nothing left!" This was a shining moment when I felt sorry for this guy, and I was pretty freaked out that he was essentially just a few organs inside a robot suit.
I guess overall, the new
Robocop could have been a pretty good movie if it got rid of Murphy's dumb family, his useless friend, and didn't pretend that it was
Robocop. As a stand-alone sci-fi movie about a man being used like a drone against his will, it could have worked out fine. I just wished it didn't pretend to be
Robocop! It just didn't have the same 80's charm that the original had. Also, the violence was dumbed down, and that also made me mad. I enjoyed the ultra-violence in the original.
This is how I feel about each movie:
Hollywood, please try to come up with some original ideas. Please don't reboot movies that don't need it, either.